No.1 Opportunity for 2025 [Take Action Now!]

Starlink's potential IPO Could Be the Biggest in History--Silicon Valley insider James Altucher has uncovered a way to profit BEFORE the IPO--with as little as $50. Musk's $180B giant is set to launch--will you miss out? Claim your spot before it's too late.

Can the IRS revoke Harvard's tax-exempt status?

GABRIELA AOUN ANGUEIRA and THALIA BEATY
April 17, 2025

For more than a century, the majority of colleges and universities have not paid most taxes. The Revenue Act of 1909 excused nonprofits operating "exclusively for religious, charitable, or educational purposes" in order to continue acting in the public interest.

President Donald Trump is looking to challenge that designation, complaining that colleges and universities are "indoctrinating" their students with "radical left" ideas, rather than educating them. And he has decided to start with the 488-year old Harvard University, one of the world's most prestigious institutions of learning and the first college founded in the American colonies.

On Tuesday, he targeted Harvard University in a post on his social media site, questioning whether it should remain tax-exempt "if it keeps pushing political, ideological, and terrorist inspired/supporting "Sickness?" Remember, Tax Exempt Status is totally contingent on acting in the PUBLIC INTEREST!"

Tax-exempt status, which is decided by the Internal Revenue Service, means that these institutions do not pay certain kinds of taxes and that their donors receive a tax deduction when they make gifts. The rules they have to follow to maintain that status are set out in the tax code. We spoke with attorneys who specialize in nonprofit law and freedom of speech to try to answer questions about this challenge.

Does a university's curriculum affect its charitable status?

In general, no. Colleges and universities have broad leeway to design the education they provide.

Genevieve Lakier, a First Amendment scholar at the University of Chicago Law School, said the U.S. Supreme Court has laid out four essential freedoms for colleges and universities -- what to teach, how to teach it, who their students are and who their professors are.

"That's the irreducible core of academic freedom and it is constitutionally protected in this country," she said, adding the government cannot threaten funding cuts or revoking a school's tax status as punishment for its views or what the school teaches.

The First Amendment also protects the rights of other nonprofits to pursue their charitable missions under freedom of assembly, Lakier said, even if those missions are odious or the government does not like them.

Can the president ask the IRS to revoke a nonprofit's tax-exempt status?

No, he is not supposed to, according to two nonprofit tax attorneys who wrote about a previous call from Trump to revoke the nonprofit status of colleges and universities.

In 1998, Congress passed a law that forbade federal officials from telling the IRS to investigate any taxpayer in an effort to increase trust in tax enforcement.

The attorneys, Ellen Aprill and Samuel Brunson, also pointed to legislation that forbade the IRS "from targeting individuals and organizations for ideological reasons," after a controversy over how it treated Tea Party groups in 2013.

How does a nonprofit get and keep its tax-exempt status?

The IRS recognizes multiple reasons for a nonprofit to to be exempt from paying many kinds of taxes, including pursuing charitable, religious or educational missions among many other examples. The statute specifically names sports competitions, preventing cruelty to children or animals and defending human or civil rights as exempt purposes.

Nonprofits can lose their tax-exempt status for things like improperly paying its directors, endorsing a political candidate or operating a business unrelated to its charitable mission.

In short, tax attorneys say nonprofits must operate "exclusively for charitable purposes," which is a different standard than what the president referred to as, "acting in the public interest."

Phil Hackney, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said, "Long history and precedent suggest that Harvard and institutions of higher education are operating for educational purposes, which are considered charitable," under the tax code.

He said it would be exceedingly difficult to make a case that a college or university was not operating for charitable purposes under current law. However, Edward McCaffery, who teaches tax policy at the University of Southern California Gould School of Law, warned there is precedent for the IRS revoking the tax-exempt status of colleges that the government could lean on.

"I think to dismiss it out of hand as over-the-top bluster and that the administration has no power to unilaterally pursue it, I think that's naive," McCaffery said. "This could happen."

Has the IRS ever stripped a college of its tax-exempt status before?

Yes. In 1983, the Supreme Court upheld a lower court decision that the IRS could deny tax-exempt status to Bob Jones University, a private Christian university that banned interracial dating and marriage on campus, and Goldsboro Christian Schools, which employed racially discriminatory admissions policies.

The court found the IRS had some discretion to determine whether an organization seeking tax-exempt status met standards of "charity," meaning that it "must serve a public purpose and not be contrary to established public policy."

Nonetheless, McCaffery said, "The ability of the IRS just to come in and deny tax exemption, it better be a very clear, long-standing, deeply held public policy, and not political preferences for certain kinds of positions, attitudes and voting patterns."

How can the IRS revoke a nonprofit's tax-exempt status?

Usually, the IRS would open an audit, where it gathers evidence that a nonprofit is not operating exclusively for charitable purposes.

"The IRS would have to send to Harvard a proposed revocation of its status," Hackney said. "At that point, Harvard would have many different means to talk with the IRS about why they believed they were within the law," including suing.

However, Hackney said the U.S. Department of Treasury could implement new regulations, for example, stating that operating a diversity, equity and inclusion program is not consistent with charitable purposes. Such a change would usually take years to make and would run counter to decades of precedent, Hackney said.

"I am skeptical this effort will be successful," he said. "If it were, this would be the most dramatic change of charitable law in my lifetime and I would say in the history of our charitable law."

___

Associated Press coverage of philanthropy and nonprofits receives support through the AP's collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content. For all of AP's philanthropy coverage, visit https://apnews.com/hub/philanthropy.

Continue Reading...

Popular

Elon's Greatest Invention... Hidden in South Memphis? - Ad

Tech legend Jeff Brown recently traveled to the industrial zone of South Memphis to investigate what he believes will be Elon's greatest invention ever... Yes, even bigger than Tesla or SpaceX.

Ex-Cellmate Says Epstein Was Offered Plea Deal for Information on Trump: 'Give Them Something on Trump To Get Him Impeached'

Jeffrey Epstein was allegedly offered a plea deal by federal prosecutors. The deal was contingent on Epstein providing information on President Trump, as claimed by Epstein's former cellmate.

Biggest Dividend Payout in U.S. History: $1 Trillion up for Grabs! - Ad

Trump just launched a $1 trillion National Investment Fund to replace income taxes and send direct payouts to Americans. You could claim up to $21,307--before the first public checks go out. This is historic. Act now to be first in line.

Meet the Key Five People Who Are Shaping Trump's Economic Agenda

In the midst of a broad tariff agenda that has caused turmoil in financial markets, President Trump is relying on a diverse group of economic advisers to guide his policies.

Why Elon Really Bought Twitter - Ad

When Musk bought Twitter for $44B, most thought he was crazy. But hidden behind the deal was his real mission-building the world's most powerful AI inside a secretive "Area 51" in Memphis. Jeff Brown just found a backdoor in-before June 1.

Dogecoin, Shiba Inu Spike But Floki And Bonk Are Stars Of Monday's Meme Rally

Memecoins were up in the green Monday overnight, with Floki and Bonk leading the charge following Bitcoin's (CRYPTO: BTC) reclaim of $95,000.

Rocket Lab Stock Is Shooting Higher Thursday: What's Fueling The Launch?

Rocket Lab USA Inc (NASDAQ:RKLB) shares are trading higher Thursday after the company announced it was selected by Kratos Defense & Security Solutions Inc (NASDAQ:KTOS) to provide a hypersonic test flight for the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD).

The Most Important "AI Stock" You've Never Heard Of - Ad

The AI revolution is moving faster than anyone expected. But what no one is talking about is the one company AI simply can't exist without. It may be the single most important AI investment, yet most people don't even know its name. For now. The moment Wall Street catches on, this $20 stock could explode.

Trump Wishes Happy Easter To All Including 'Radical Left Lunatics' And 'Weak And Ineffective Judges': Truth Social Posts Gets Slammed

President Donald Trump's Easter messages on Sunday stirred controversy as they shifted from traditional holiday greetings to sharp political attacks on Joe Biden, judges, and the 2020 election.

Trump's AI Education Push, Cramer's AI Stock Optimism, And More: This Week In Artificial Intelligence

Week full of AI news: Trump advocates for AI education, Cramer bullish on AI stocks, Amazon and Nvidia dismiss data center fears, OpenAI's restructuring raises concerns, Nadella's Microsoft introduces AI updates.

Gold Is Breaking Records. This Stock Hasn't Moved Yet. - Ad

With gold over $3,200, one near-term producer is still trading like a developer. But the mill is running, crews are working underground, and first production is months away.

Trump's Autonomous Vehicles Stance, Bezos Vs. Tesla, And More: This Week In Mobility

Autonomous driving & EV have seen significant developments this week: Trump's change of heart, Bezos-backed startups, & Tesla's declining sales.

Saudi Arabia and Qatar to pay back Syria's debt to the World Bank

BEIRUT (AP) — Saudi Arabia and Qatar said Sunday they will pay Syria’s outstanding debt to the World Bank, a move likely to make the international institution resume its support to the war-torn country.

The World's First Multi-Trillion-Dollar Robotics Industry... - Ad

Wall Street and Big Tech are scrambling. A $24 trillion robot revolution is already underway--and one tiny $7 stock is at the center. Microsoft, Tesla, and Google have bet billions. Bill Gates says it's "as revolutionary as the PC." This could impact 65M Americans by August.

Gentex Q1 Impacted By Tariff Uncertainty, Suspends Mirror Production For Chinese Market

Gentex shares fall as Q1 results reflect tariff pressures, prompting a halt in China-bound mirror production and a lowered 2025 sales outlook.

Is Norfolk Southern 'making it right' after Ohio derailment? New lawsuit adds to doubts

Norfolk Southern began making promises to East Palestine, Ohio, soon after its train in February 2023, saying it would after five tank cars of vinyl chloride were intentionally burned, sending up a huge black plume of smoke that spread more toxic chemicals over homes, schools and farms.

Brace Yourself for Jeff Bezos' "Amazon Helios" - Ad

Amazon delivers 20 million packages a day... powers some of the most popular websites... delivers medication to half of the U.S. population... and even produces award-winning films and TV shows. But a Wall Street legend -- twice featured on 60 Minutes -- predicts that "Amazon Helios" will be bigger than all of those... COMBINED.

CEOs Say Container Trade Growth Increasingly Tracks Global GDP, But Tariff Risks Loom

CEOs say that container trade growth is increasingly tracking global GDP, signaling a stable market, but tariff risks loom.

A bushel of fruit and vegetable motifs give decor a healthy farmstand vibe

Interior designer and stylist Jonny Carmack has a “fruit room” in his Danbury, Connecticut, home. Colorful faux produce bedecks every inch, from the cherry-shaped ceiling fixture to a strawberry side table and a bunch of other juicy gems in decorative forms.

No.1 Opportunity for 2025 [Take Action Now!] - Ad

Starlink's potential IPO Could Be the Biggest in History--Silicon Valley insider James Altucher has uncovered a way to profit BEFORE the IPO--with as little as $50. Musk's $180B giant is set to launch--will you miss out? Claim your spot before it's too late.

Surveillance video shows New York-to-Paris flight stowaway slipping past gate agents

NEW YORK (AP) — The woman who was able to sneak onto a New York-to-Paris flight without a boarding pass late last year was able to get on the plane by glomming onto a group of ticketed passengers as they passed gate agents, new surveillance video shows.

Nvidia Is About to Shock the World: July 23rd - Ad

Jeff Brown, the tech legend who picked shares of Nvidia in 2016 before they jumped by more than 22,000%, is warning everyone to... Mark this date on your calendar: July 23rd! That's when Nvidia could help send shares of this Elon Musk supplier skyrocketing higher.

This CEO Says Tariff Uncertainty Is Actually Good for His Business

John Santora, the CEO of WeWork, has revealed that the current economic uncertainty due to tariffs is driving an increase in business for the coworking space company.

Eli Lilly Set To Report Earnings As Investors Eye Weight Loss Drug Momentum

Eli Lilly (LLY) will report Q1 results on Thursday. Analysts expect in line results with focus on tirizepatide and obesity franchise.

One Coin to Rule Them All... - Ad

Hardly any investors are talking about this coin but I believe that's about to change with some potentially huge news! Get in on the ground floor while it's rock bottom with this new how-to guide, just $3.

How bugs and beet juice could play roles in the race to replace artificial dyes in food

ST. LOUIS (AP) — As pressure grows to get out of the U.S. food supply, the shift may well start at Abby Tampow’s laboratory desk.

China lashes out at US as tensions escalate over a space observatory in Chile

SANTIAGO, Chile (AP) — China struck a defiant stance on Tuesday in response to American concerns about Beijing's efforts to expand its influence in the resource-rich South American nation of Chile, escalating tensions over a Chinese astronomical venture in Chile’s arid north.

World Economic Forum: "Arguably the Most Exciting Human Discovery Since Fire" - Ad

Sam Altman, Bill Gates, and Mark Zuckerberg are all investing vast sums of money into a radical technology. According to Bloomberg, this could become 10 times bigger than AI, quantum computing, electric vehicles, cryptocurrencies, and robotics combined. And one stock is at the center of it all.

SEC Chair Paul Atkins Says Crypto Deserves Clear Regulatory Rules, Praises 'Crypto Mom' Hester Peirce's Efforts

New Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Paul Atkins indicated a friendlier approach toward cryptocurrency during his tenure on Friday, highlighting the need for a clear regulatory policy to help the industry thrive in the U.S.

Jim Farley Says Ford Will Delay Price Hike To See How Rivals React To Tariffs

Ford delays price hike for vehicles as CEO Jim Farley says they will monitor competitors' response and provide updates later.

A New Gold Discovery in Red Lake? - Ad

Two new gold anomalies just lit up the maps. They sit right beside a restart-ready mine-and follow the exact fold pattern that's made Red Lake world famous.

China says it's evaluating US overtures for trade talks, but tariffs remain an obstacle

BEIJING (AP) — China’s Commerce Ministry said Friday that Beijing is evaluating multiple approaches by the Trump administration for trade talks.

You Can Take a Stake in Elon's xAI Before June 1st... - Ad

Elon Musk's private AI firm xAI may have just leapfrogged ChatGPT and Google's Gemini--building what experts call the future of AI. For the first time, you can take a stake starting at $500.

Tesla Stock Skyrockets 20% Following Elon Musk's Return and Shift From DOGE

Tesla shares have experienced a 20% surge following the announcement of CEO Elon Musk's return to the company.

Trending Now

Information, charts or examples are for illustration and educational purposes only and not for individualized investment management This message contains commercial elements, such as advertising. We only send these offers to those who have opted in to our newsletter. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For these reasons we strongly suggest trading in a DEMO/Simulated account. The information provided by us is for educational and informational purposes only. We make no representations or warranties concerning the products, practices or procedures of any company or entity mentioned or recommended and have not determined if the statements and opinions of the advertiser are accurate, correct or truthful. If you use, act upon or make decisions in reliance on information contained or any external source linked within it, you do so at your own peril and agree to hold us, our officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates and agents without fault.

Copyright 2025 trendadvisor.net
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service